Wednesday, September 15, 2010

Christine O'Donnell, Conservative

With the same intensity that I felt I could not support Scott Brown, I DO support Christine O'Donnell. One of the gripes that I had with Mr. Brown is that I sensed the conformist in him. He held strong to his beliefs on Health Care, and then caved on virtually every other piece of legislation that came before him. If he had been following conservative ideals, those votes should have taken care of themselves.

Christine O'Donnell believes in something, wholly and completely. That she is Catholic is beside the point. I'm happy that she is Catholic, though I'd have to check up on what she believes about Social Justice. These votes that come to them should not be very difficult if you are confident about who you are and what you believe in. When someone says they have a lot of "soul searching" to do, what they are really saying is that they have not figured out what the majority of their friends (or supporters) think about the subject or vote at hand.

That she can come out with a belief system and then not flinch when the media anal probe comes along speaks volumes about her. I will watch her with interest as the election comes upon us.

The establishment Republicans are in a tizzy going on and on about how they are going to lose the seat and the chance of a majority with her upset win over the RINO Castle. I can not believe that those people in the RNC can be so dense. Let me be very clear and simple here for the RNC leadership: if you have 55 Republicans in the Senate and 45 Democrats in the Senate, do you have a majority? Mathematically, yes. However, if 6 of them are RINOs, then the reality of the situation is a resounding, "NO". Why do you think they have the title, "Republican In Name Only" hung about their necks? Winning is not the end upon itself, remaining true to Conservative ideals is the goal.

What this election in Delaware means for the RNC is that they have a CHANCE of electing a conservative to the post who will actually vote that way. Not another Scott Brown who, "has to live in the reality of a Blue State". Vote your conscience, that is why people voted for you to occupy that office. If Castle had held on to the seat, then the Democrats would simply have another de facto vote that they could count on in a clutch situation. Bipartisan to a Democrat simply means that the RINOs agree with them. Odd how the Democrats are never accused of voting lock-step on issues...

Get on with it, Christine. Fellow Gen-X'er. Lets show the country what a person of principles is capable of doing in office.

--Zavost




Tuesday, September 14, 2010

Leadership, Character, and Virtue

This past week I had some interesting discussions with some acquaintances and a recurring theme kept coming up about leadership, trust, honesty, integrity, and so on. We were talking about how you can recognize positive traits in people during interviews to minimize the possibility of hiring a smooth-talking, literate loser.

Politics was brought up at times, others it was specific examples of people we knew or had met in the past. For this discussion from the Stoa, I'm just unburdening myself of a few points that I made that I feel bear repeating, if even into my personal journal.

From time to time, I encountered confusion about what some of the words actually meant and how they were supposed to be applied. Some second-level thinking was needed to get behind the facade and get to the meat of what we were supposed to be talking about.

When a corporation, small business, or even voter is seeking to hire or elect a good person for a position, they are usually looking for similar traits in people. They want to know that they are first competent, then trustworthy, then a good member of the team. We can quibble on the order, but the gist of this is all the same. If you are hiring someone to look after and to grow a multi-million (or billion) dollar company, you want to ensure that they know how to grow money and reduce expenses. You also want to make sure that they will follow the rules and the law in the way they go about their work (ethics). Of course, you also what to know that you can trust what they are saying, since you have your own job to perform.

This a refrain that I once heard the great Rush Limbaugh utter back in the 90's when he was talking about then-President Bill Clinton. I was too distracted at the time to think about it, but he spoke a truth that at hung with me since. He said that, "Leadership descends from character". In general I think that this is an accurate statement. Though over the years since then, as I grew older and studied Stoicism I had to reject that statement only because I felt it used the wrong word. Leadership descends from Virtue.

For years I struggled with how someone like a Jimmy Carter, Bill Clinton, or Barak Obama can so willingly inflict policies on the country that force us into a declining cultural condition. Then, at some point, it came to me that a person's character can be either good or bad, depending on the subjective point of view. To all the frothing lunatics that willing follow a Nancy Pelosi or a Barak Obama, the character of these individuals in impeccable. From my point of view they are wasting good, breathable air. Those that agree with Pelosi simply have different values and beliefs then I. Good and bad are rather subjective...until you look at method, mode, and motive. Things get clearer there and begin to cross deeply into my thoughts on Virtue.

A good, quick definition of virtue looks like this: "Virtue (Latin virtus; Greek ἀρετή "arete") is moral excellence. A virtue is a trait or quality deemed to be morally excellent and thus is valued as a foundation of principle and good moral being." The Greeks were brilliant and their language reflected their desire to get things not just right, but exactly right. Morality by its definition is "good". Amorality is "bad". We are seeking someone who will make money for us, not embezzle it. If a person's character allows them to use taxpayer money to hire fifty body guards and drive a fleet of Cadillac Escalades around is not practicing a moral virtue, Mr. Former Detroit Mayor. A Speaker that purchases her a private jet to fly back and forth from San Francisco every week, even though there have been Speakers in the past from the west coast who got by on less, is not practicing fiduciary restraint. This person, though wealthy enough on their own to operate this craft every week still permits the taxpayer to pay for this jet and its operation. Not a virtuous act. Virtue is not subjective to the observer. It is an absolute truth. Killing someone for fun is amoral. Killing someone in self-defense is not. War is amoral by nature, but serving humanity by keeping liberty alive is a moral act.

Seeking someone of good character is simply not good enough. They must be able to demonstrate Virtue. Leadership descends from Virtue. Honesty is a Virtue. Purchasing real estate in a desert and then having it rezoned under your board for a profitable re-sale is not virtuous, Mr. Reid. Owning a multi-million dollar compound while making a very low six-figure income and not explaining how you happened to come by the compound is not virtuous, Mr. Biden. Likewise, hiring a person to run a business who simply drives the share price up for a year-end bonus is not the right CEO either.

Since I brought up the CEO, I'll talk about them in a little more detail. In this new(er) climate of paying an executive a multiple of their lowest payed employee (does not work well in Japan, so lets bring it here) would drive out the good CEOs and send them to over-seas competition. All that Socialist crap plays well in the media but not outside the land of "make believe". For years CEOs have had compensation tied to stock performance as a bonus on top of their base salary, which may actually be a 20:1 multiple of their entry level folks. A CEO that wants to earn $20,000,000 per year on a $250,000 salary will be focused on getting their stocks to perform. A virtuous CEO will make the company stronger and more competitive; more effective. One without virtue will manipulate the books, play with the market, drop hints in speeches (insider trading) and suck up to the politicians in power: yes, I'm talking to you Mr. Immelt. Simply "playing by the rules" is not good enough. You have to do the right thing, regardless of whether anyone is watching or even if your pay will suffer. You are either working for the good of a company, its shareholders, its employees, and its customers, or you are simply trying to get rich. Getting rich is a noble pursuit, as long as it is done virtuously: no, I AM NOT talking to you Mr. Soros. If you are manipulating stock for your own enrichment, you are not working at my company.

From the viewpoints of a Ms. Pelosi, Mr. Reid, and a President Obama, they feel that they are doing the right thing, perhaps, by trying to turn the United States into a Socialist Utopia. My wife feels they are in it only for money and power. She is usually right about these things...but I digress from my esoteric points. They can not get the electorate to go along with them normally, so they call them "stupid, religious, and overly patriotic". This is done to demean their opposition so that they can feel better about bending, braking, or otherwise ignoring the Constitution, Federal case law, and cultural customs in order to make their vision of the United States the only vision of the United States. This is NOT virtuous at all. They may tip the newspaper boy (what are these "newspapers" of which you speak) for Christmas (oops, I mean MLK day), be good fathers and mothers at home, but they are amoral and demonstrating vice when they are entrusted with the vital responsibilities of government.

I'm sure your feet and buttock are hurting at the base of the Stoa from such an esoteric discussion, but I do feel better. Over the years it bugged me how we could keep electing people who are so OBVIOUSLY deficient in both character and virtues to office, election after election. People simply do not recognize the semantic differences between character and virtue. They think that just because Obama is black (well, half black) that he is owed the position. That his election will somehow expunge our national guilt over slavery, or that he will be a moderate are simply not using their critical thinking skills. Look back at my posting on the educational system and this will be clearer to all of you about why people can not think empirically any longer.

Leadership does descend from Character, however, the character must be measured against virtue.

The Stoa is free for the next teacher. Use it well


Friday, September 3, 2010

Cogito ergo sum

I am often times exasperated with what the schools are tying to push onto our kids. The secondary schools are nothing more than indoctrination camps, pure and simple.

When my parents were in the public school system, they had rigorous standards to meet and were more advanced in every subject then I was at a similar age and level of development. They were educated by the aging Missionary Generation and the GI generation folks. I was educated by the very last of the GI generation and the youngish Boomers. My children are being educated by aging Boomers and compliant Gen-Xer's with a smattering of hippy Millenials. With the new school season upon us, I am not looking forward to spending my nights making sure that historical gaps are filled, historical context is added, explanations of why it rains, why is the sky blue, and that all sentences must be ended with a period (that one is for my 11 year old son who is still working on this).

The other day, my son complained to me that most of what I make him learn at night (yes, even in the summer time) has no relevance with what they are learning in school. What he is really doing is blaming the school rather than his work ethic. However, he correct to an extent. Here is what is on my chest today and this is what will come from the Stoa as well.

In my parent's time, students were taught, mostly, by rote memorization. They knew their math tables backwards and forwards. They knew and understood sentence structure, syntax and grammar. They could name all 48 States (and then the two new ones in 1959) plus their capitals. Sometimes, they would have to list the states and their capitals by alphabetical order, sometimes even in reverse order. Tedious, you bet, but they KNEW them. Knew them cold and can still recite them all these years later. My education was haphazard to say the least. I had a mixture of the Old Guard and the "new" everything. I was not taught phonics because it was thought to stifle creativity. I was not taught syntax and grammar. I was taught "new math" whereby in the last week of school I was still answering questions from chapter one and they "built" on new topics each week/month. All this did was slow down my rate of learning, and what I did learn was not deep enough to get anything better than a general grasp of what it was about, no time for mastery or deeper contemplation. Those Old Guard teachers I remember were beaten down by the new system and were just marking time for retirement. My loss. Most of my education is "self-taught". I have a vast number of books that go back more than 100 years, sometimes before the Progressive movement of the early 20th century. I have school books from the 1880's with subjects such as grammar, rhetoric (you may have to look that word up), and religion. Oh, yes, religion was a big part of our public education in the 19th century. I must thank my Grandmother for allowing me to take a share of the family library when she moved into a smaller home after the death of my grandfather back in 1979. That was the seed that helped me to compare what is in books today vs the 19th and early 20th centuries. Context. I had to teach myself nearly everything because I was so woefully unprepared when I graduated from High School. Don't even get me started about my first year of college.

My children are getting the full effects of this liberal progressive mind-wipe that is called public education. They are taught about the biosphere, the food web (it is not even a chain anymore, I guess), environmentalism, a skewed history, and social activism. Their grasp of history is embarrassing. Reading through their textbooks is like skipping through a book and re-writing history in such a way that you feel that that the United States is responsible for every evil in the world. Picking and sorting through actual history to attempt to prove their points. Shoving it at children who are not capable of critical thinking and simply store the data away for a test. My children are learning two versions of history and political science. There is the school lessons and then the real history. I untwist the context that school offers and explain how things let up to certain events and what happened afterwards (the unintended consequences).

What I'm working towards here is trying to give my children some depth and the tools to think for themselves. My daughter is a bright one. She is "self-teaching" herself without me. Makes a father proud. She regularly researches items and topics that she feels are connected to the back story of a historical event and then discusses those items with me. She is drawing conclusions and then forming a position that can be defended logically. There have been times where she has reminded me of a fact that I had forgotten that forced me to alter my positions. Yes, very proud of her.

Then this leads me to my discussion with my son the other day. Again, he was complaining that I am holding him to a standard beyond that of the school. He gets mostly A's with a few B's (a C in music) and is wondering why his mother and I stay on him (her school system is still like that of my parents' system and she frequently rubs my nose in this point). I attempted to explain to him that getting an A in the subjects they are teaching is relatively meaningless. They are supposed to be grading his comprehension and mastery of progressively more difficult subjects of knowledge. The fact that he has the penmanship of a dying chicken, the spelling of a six year old, and the attention span of a newt means that the school is failing him. He is a very bright boy and I will not let a good mind go to waste. The schools have gone through a long decline of "catering to the lowest denominator" and that if he is getting an "A", then that simply means that he is in the upper third of the class (grade inflation and all that). I had to describe to him what the term "denominator" meant when he was several weeks into studying fractions since the teacher did not feel it an important term to know.

Think back to what Universities used to be. In the late 18th century, they were only for the rich and influential. In the 19th century, they were still for the privileged, though more and more individuals were able to get into them with the rising wealth of the middle class. They were places of rigorous, and I mean rigorous study. If you read the biographies of people from that time you will note the dates of their accomplishments. Climbed such and such place, swam this or that channel, worked in the family business and invented this or that. When you see their university years, it is simply a four year chunk of time that is blank, other than what they did in and for the university (some notable exceptions like Theodore Roosevelt). The point is, they did nothing else but study their butts off, for four straight years, night and day. In secondary school, it was a given that you had mastered the elements of learning. You had learned your math tables, your grammar, your history, your Latin, all the facts dates and figures that give depth to an educated person. Remember, often times people were too busy farming or working to support large families and were unable to complete their secondary schooling. The University was where one learned how to think. Learned how to problem solve. Learned how to LEARN. Most importantly, they learned how to think for themselves and to question everything around them.

The Boomers resented the way they were oppressed in school and sought to lighten thing up a bit and aim for "happy and self-actualized individuals". Too much pressure, too many rules, and too much emphasis on results. The Progressive movement made a resounding comeback with this generation. They knocked God out of the classroom, pushed the flag and the Pledge of Allegiance out as well. God and country have to be eradicated if the Progressive movement is to gain ultimate victory. If one believes in God, then one believes in an absolute right and wrong. If one believes that something is wrong, then it is to be avoided. This ultimately leads to groups of people telling others how to think and be held to a higher standard. Patriotism brings about a belief that your nation or country is somehow singled out for greatness. The concept of Trans-Nationalism is anathema to our Constitutional Republic. So we must eliminate the support of the Flag by burning and defacing the principles upon which we were founded. Self inflicted generational amnesia. The young Americans of today must think in terms of global participation and not the simple nation-state. The Pledge of Allegiance is dangerous and even offensive (not) to the vast number of immigrants in our country. So children, my daughter included, are not permitted to pray during the 9/11 remembrances, there is no flag in their classroom to pledge their patriotism, and there are no pictures of George Washington or Abraham Lincoln to stare at when they are bored.

Hitler knew that you had to grab the children and teach them. Their take over of the nation's collective philosophy would be cemented with them, not the extermination of their parents. Stalin (Lenin) and Mao worked the same angles. The Progressives have done the same things here by dumbing down the educational standards so that our children will simply accept the drivel that is being shoveled at them. They think there is nothing wrong with swapping out light bulbs or forcing people to carry health insurance. They think that forced redistribution of wealth is FAIR and that to complain about it is to place you under suspicion. All of this has happened in my lifetime. I am now old enough to have seen what things were like just before me and now to see what they are doing today.

Cogito ergo sum. I think, therefore I am. Just because you are aware of yourself does not make you an individual thinker. Think on that and the consequences of failing to teach our young how to think for themselves.

The Stoa is now empty, please teach responsibly.

--Zavost

Tuesday, August 31, 2010

The Reality Bubble

Reality really is relative, as described by both Psychologists and Physicists. Fairly recent theoretical discoveries in M-Theory (String Theory for those keeping score from home) seem to indicate that every moment that passes in our lives can be perceived in three dimensions; as I look around my dining room right now, I see a Maroon-Bellied Conure approximately two meters in front of me and a stove three meters to my right. If I wish to get up and go down the hallway, my objective reality can perceive the obstacles along my course of travel and plan accordingly. Yet, at the same moment, everything is also being projected, in two dimensions onto the surface of the expanding wave-front of the cosmos. However, since I am still typing this, I have chosen not to get up. Yet not just the events of me continuing to type are being projected onto this expanding surface, but even the act of me getting up to check out the refrigerator have also been projected nearby. I am still typing, yet in an endless fracturing of the possibilities of space-time, I did indeed get up to check out the left overs from last night's dinner. I can not perceive that reality, yet it did, both objectively and subjectively occur elsewhere. It occurred elsewhere and else-when, though it is impossible for me to either see (since the 2-d projection is retreating, at some times, faster than the speed of light) or otherwise perceive that event.

Reality sure can be a hoot, can it not?

People have a reality bubble around them that is not necessarily based on objective reality, rather it is based on highly personal subjective reality. Many call this a "world-view", I like to think of it as a "reality-filter". The filter is specifically designed and created by the individual to promote a stable psychological gestalt of self. Events of self reflection and introspection can sometimes lead one to alter their filters and thereby alter their perception of reality. I believe that this is something most people do as they grow older and mature their self-image. There are plenty of ex-hippies who protested the Vietnam War, protested the draft, and told the government to stay out of their lives (you're oppressing us, maaaannn), yet are now the same ones that send our young men off to war (who, by and large are quite willing), propose a new draft in the interest of fairness ( Charlie Rangle), and are now telling me that the very air I exhale is a poisonous and toxic material. Boy, have their filters undergone an alteration. When I ask these individuals (common folk like me that just happen to be the supporters of those individuals) the answer I get back is a perplexing look, hand gesticulations, and a sentence that trails off that usually ends like, "but this is........different". Right.

What I have trouble understanding is how an individual can be intelligent enough to develop economic or political theories that, when practiced in the real world (yes, I know, reality can be rather odd) produce failure, misery, and death squads; then proudly tell the American people that we just have not been doing enough of that economic or political theory (specifically Keynesian economics and Statism). Hello, can we recall Cambodia, Vietnam, China, Russia, and even the French Revolution? Can we recall Weimar Republic Germany, Zimbabwe (Rhodesia) or Argentina; heck, even the PIIG nations of Southern Europe. Germany just had the best economic upswing in 20 years and STILL posted a more than doubling of their budget debt! How long does or can this go one before people figure it out and think to themselves that spending away the future of your children for self-gratification (or aggrandizement) today is not the right way to go? Perhaps trying to control how a person lives, eats, dresses, consumes, or yes, dare I say it, breathes, may not be the best things for us to be doing?

What is their motivation for the destruction of the American way of life? What can possibly appeal to our political leaders about the European and Asian concepts of Communism and Statism? Power, the lust for glory and historical remembrance? Can we be so base as that?

According to my wife, yes. We can be and, deep down, most of us are. Having grown up on the other side of the Iron Curtain, her reality is frequently at odds with mine. She sees my world view as being unrealistically optimistic and incredibly simple at times. She sees the military as a tool of oppression, not liberation by those in power and she sees those who serve their careers in the military as being good for nothing productively else in society (present military excluded, of course). Should I try to alter her subjective reality? No. Actually, upon self-reflection the vast history of our culture has indeed been one of oppression, power and plunder. America is a unique experiment, blessed by God and given an opportunity to be the exception, not the rule.

The time has come where America is at an historical evolutionary cross-roads. We can either stay true to our heritage or we can follow the well-worn path of central control of both the material and the imaginary (thought, creativity, expression and the like). The Progressives have done their level best to slowly destroy our heritage and make it easy for us to accept the chains of Statism. We have been lulled into a waking dream and pulled, step by step, decade by decade down the path of Statism and it is only a very, very short step to complete the process. We are waking up to the danger and have been stirring since the times of Ronald Reagan, but we have been pulled hard lately and maybe enough people have not been awoken.

The subjective reality for me is grim. I am afraid for where this country has been going and what the 60's liberals have done to both my future and those of my children. The objective reality is that we will just have to live with it and change it where it is within my power to change. Progressives and Statists (is there a difference?) are getting their subjective and objective realties to line up. I have to wonder if the masses of them will not, when they are older and have seen yet another failure, a large and impressive failure on the scale of the United States, alter their perception filters to see what they and those like them wrought upon the world?

Perhaps, perhaps not. Maybe there is no single reality that is "right" or "correct". Maybe things just "are". In Quantum Theory, human thought is able to affect the outcome of experiments that are "either/or" results. I wonder if enough of us thought a certain way we can affect reality and get things to turn our way in the end. You know, I believe that this is possible. A wise man, more than 2,000 years ago caused a book to come into being and he said something along those lines. What we call "desires" today, they called "prayer" then. If enough of us pray for deliverance, then deliverance will come. Now, this is very odd that science can discover, or theoretically outline something that has been the exclusive realm of religion for millennia. The Catholic church is correct to say that science and religion (today) do not have to be mutually exclusive. Just as Issac Newton, who edited a bible or Albert Einstein who stated that the perfection of the Universe could not have been an accident.

I think it is time for me to go study my reality filters and perform some more introspective tune-ups.

The Stoa is open.

--Zavost

Thursday, August 19, 2010

God Bless You, Ronald Reagan

A rare individual. Men like him, willing to stand up and tell you what how it is, regardless of personal political cost. No matter how hard I look, I can not find a single man in the political arena today who is able to articulate the conservative message with such clarity. He was a patriot and he infected those who heard him with this patriotism. I am a Reagan child, come to my maturity under his Presidency. I learned that to get somewhere in life you must work hard and hope for success, though failure is ALWAYS an option. Learn from those failures and try again. The children of Clinton learned how to dodge the truth and look 'cool' doing it. The children of G.W. Bush learned how to keep their heads down, both on the battlefield and in public, since to support him brought scorn. The children of Obama will learn how to tolerate only Islam in their lives, while at the same time, thinking that you can spend your way out of debt.

I really miss you Ronaldus Magnus.

One of his great speeches, recorded while stumping for Barry Goldwater in 1964, is included below. It is fairly long, but worth the time.


--Zavost

Tuesday, August 17, 2010

The coming Collectivist Nightmare

The YouTube link below sums up the hard right turn of the American public since the election of BHO. Many have known, deep down, that this cancer was here in the States, but we never really wanted to believe it. Most of us just kept getting up and expecting our lives to remain on the upward curve. Watch the link below and the various Tea Parties will be better understood. It will also give you some insight into the assumptive lords and masters of the "New Republic" under Progressive control.


America has never been a "collective" nation. From our very beginnings we were scattered and few. Families and extended family groups founded villages and outposts along the frontiers, taking risks that could and frequently did, take the lives of their loved ones. The only involvement from the "government" was a land grant title and a vague notation about the boundaries and location of said plot of land. That was it. There was no police or social services present. They were on their own. Waves of immigrants fled Europe as the nation-state continued to tighten its grip in their native lands. They came to our growing, filthy cities that were a den for machine politics to make a living in manufacturing. Others went into the frontier to carve out their lives, far from the influence of Washington, and farther yet from the old landholders that had power over their lives in the old country. Pioneering was a dangerous life, but it was their lives. They kept what they farmed, sold what they wished to whomever they wished.

Today I listen to Democrats explain how they must be given more power to control the actions of the American people. I hear a Michigan Democrat tell me that the health care bill is more about controlling the lifestyles of the people than it is about the delivery of healthcare. Obama neuters NASA by forcing it to contract to the private sector for its mission vehicles, yet he takes over GM and Chrysler. What's with that? Congress comes back into session to pull together another unaffordable bailout package, this time for his teacher union buddies even as a myriad of economic indices warn us of a massive unraveling of the American economy.

The Democrats are ruling, not running this country now. They are working frantically to get their legislation into place before the great bloodletting coming in November. They hope to root these power grabs deep into the political fabric of the government; too rooted and 'popular' for the Republicans to rip out (assuming they can muster the will and the spine). The Federal government is trying to centralize and collectivize everything. Look at what the Agriculture Department is doing with Sugar Beets (yes, I have a lot of time on my hands lately). The cost of everything with sugar is going to skyrocket. Hand in hand with that is the import/export ban on sugar in America. Working together, there is no way that a candy bar will be purchased with pocket change any longer. I wonder if this has anything to do with the recent assaults on salt and tasty food?

Central and Eastern Europe lived through this nightmare in the 20th century, why do we refuse to see where these policies will take us? It has been done, repeatedly, in Europe, Asia, Africa, and South America. It leads to political oppression, collectivization, poverty and death.

Americans work for the individual or those in their immediate family. They work to make their mark in the world, to make a reputation and to become rich. They take risks that harm only themselves, though some would argue that they harm the employees when they fail, but that is a red herring argument. The Federal government, up until the Progressive movement, was a distant city that did not much interfere with the rancher, or sugar beet farmer. The American Individual succeeds or fails on their own hard, intelligence, and luck.

Collectives are soul-less things. Everything is done for the "good of society". What is society? Who benefits? All of us? Why must someone have to give something up so that another can have something? Why can't that someone go out and "earn" what they need? See, right there it is. Everything is everybody's, when you get right down to it. No one will have respect for personal property because it will be everyone's and no one's. You will be unable to better your life because to do so would be to take something away from someone else.

Bees and ants will broom out the unnecessary workers and males in the fall so that the collective can better survive the coming winter. Certain types of blood cells attach themselves to invading cells and then explode to kill of the infection. When we bleed, living cells clot to close the breach. Parts of our collective sacrifice themselves for the greater whole. The Soviets in WWII threw wave after wave soldiers at the Nazis and Werhrmacht to break a front. The Chinese practiced the Zap Brannigan methodologies of warfare in the Korean War; all in the interests of the "Collective". Human life becomes worthless in that system, valued only for what it can provide to the whole.

America and Americans are not cells in a collective organization. America has been a super power because we are GREATER than the sum of our parts. Locking us into a collective body will dissipate and waste the energy and innovation that has been our hallmark for generations. All you have to do is ask yourself this: what government agency would have thought up the i-Pad and ordered it to be created by the State owned Apple Corporation? It would not have happened. The world will be a dimmer place without that spark.

Let us all hope that the Republicans have finally learned from their squandered opportunities in the last blood letting. If they have not, then they will be swept out as well. Believe it.

The Stoa is cleaned and ready for the next speaker.

--Zavost




Tuesday, August 3, 2010

Intelligent Design, what is so intelligent about it?

I read something the other day in a recent science publication that has been grating on me. A person has written a book where he hypothesizes that Intelligent Design must be true because we humans have developed such a technological civilization. That without the ability to invent and create having been "encoded" into our DNA we would be helpless in the face of Nature and its animals.

I always have to just shake my head at the basic premises of scholarship such as this. It has to make the assumption that at some time, somewhere, a great finger came down and hit the "on" button and away we went as a species; that somehow we are not a part of the natural world around us.

I subscribe to the "Occam's Razor" assumptions that the simplest, least complicated hypothesis is likely correct. If we were bio-engineered by aliens then you must ask yourself several questions: why, what for, and how much patience do they have? We've been here a while already, even if we are only 5,500 years on this globe. Have they forgotten what they put us here for? The idea of spontaneous chemical reactions that, given billions of years, will begin to replicate more complex patterns of itself is perfectly reasonable to me. It does not take an endless chain of aliens creating one another, because after all, who created that first alien?

Now, before I get bibles thrown at me please believe that I am a religious man first and foremost, as were most of our Founders. I think Thomas Jefferson would have enjoyed reading Darwin's book (and those that came before Darwin that didn't get the same press coverage) describing natural selection. I do not believe that his solid religious beliefs would have been seriously tested or bent. I find myself praying often I believe that it is good for your soul to do so. I DO NOT believe in collective salvation or the preachings of "Social Justice" that has started to spew from my local Catholic church. Your relationship with God is the only truly private relationship you can ever have in your life. However, with that out of the way, I digress.

Back to this absurd idea that without our technology we are helpless little pink (pick your color) creatures that will be savaged by the first passing squirrel. We are part of Nature. We evolved there and have been there in our modern form for at least 80,000 years. Our predecessors were there, in a fairly modern form for over 500,000 years. Technology developed slowly with ideas coming and going, being traded around, improved upon, and discarded when not needed. Collective groups are not "smart", if you have a room full of idiots, you still have a room full of idiots (substitute country or culture in the place of rooms if you like). A brilliant individual comes along and teaches the idiots something useful who will then perfect it and pass it along. Other brilliant people in other places share their ideas with other brilliant people and truly amazing things can be created. With the rise of better communication and trade, ideas have been swapped and shared at a faster and faster pace. Our capacity to learn is no different than it was 80,000 years ago, but we are certainly better off then they were.

Now that I've described how it was individuals that gave us great ideas, I'll now describe how the brilliant individual and the collective grouping (be it clan or family, but lets think small scale here for now) drove innovation in the very beginning.

Your clan is migrating to a place far to the North in 60,000 b.c. It has not been able to make good time because shelter is scarce and predators are common. A hunter, with his heavy rocks and a stick tell the group that there is a cave on the edge of a grassy savanna that would be perfect to set up longer term lodging. The problem is the huge cave bear that lives there. The not-so-smart friend of the hunter says, "no problem, one cave coming up" and walks into the cave while the rest of the hunting party watches on. The hunter smacks the bear in the face with the stick and is instantly mauled to death. The group runs away and thinks on this issue. A smarter fellow recommends throwing the rock at the bear to drive it off. So, another hunter goes into the cave and heaves his heavy rocks at the bear. The bear runs faster than the human and mauls this one as well. The group, now two men short, once again rethink this bear thing. An even smarter hunter decides that he will sharpen his stick and harden it in the flames of his campfire. He pulls up his furs and heads into the cave. He stabs the bear in the side and is instantly mauled. The group backs off again to the safety of the fire and notes that the bear was actually hurt in that attempt. The smartest person in the group has an idea, how about everyone goes in there with sharpened sticks at the same time...and he will even experiment by putting sharpened stones on the end of his spear. That fall, the clan is residing in a cave with new fur coats and a cool looking area rug. Needless to say, this clan will fare better than their less adaptable brethren and have stronger offspring. Eventually, with ingenuity and numbers; since there will be other animals and clans to punch in the nose along the way, plus those tasty looking mushrooms...hey, you, taste those and tell me if they are good...

My point being is that we have done this on our own. We should be proud of who and what we are. Enough of this collective guilt. We have dominated this planet because we are the smartest animal around by far. Our biochemistry always astounds me with its complexity. We dominate through our intelligence and ability to adapt. Accept that. We all come from about 20,000 breeding couples (that is another blog) in the south of Africa. Our genetic diversity is almost non-existent. We are more alike than any two breeds of bird or dog or cat. We are the greatest of all the primates and we are soooooo very vanilla, genetically speaking.

Now, to ask what is so intelligent about our design. Who invented the wisdom tooth? How about the appendix? Why do we get cancer and have deformed children. Who is responsible for quality control up there? Why do our arteries clog if we eat good tasting food and why is bad tasting food so good for you? Why do the mean people seem to live forever? I know, I'm drifting into philosophy and that will keep me going for hours, so I'll stick to biology. The point is that our bodies are fragile, slow moving, and prone to break down without proper, regular maintenance. God may be driving evolution towards a form perfectly suited for our future but He certainly could not be responsible for the genetics that cause diseases and other infirmities. Those must be the aliens' doing and they must be lazy, with a capital "L".

Keep in mind I'm not out to offend anyone, but if I have then you need to think real hard about your own beliefs first. If a nobody from Michigan can shake your beliefs so easily then you need to rethink your beliefs, and I mean do the soul searching type of review. Now, if you want to burn me at the stake or deny me food, shelter, education or employment because of my scribblings then you need to look at the calendar and note that it is 2010. We are supposed to be enlightened and open to free thought. Don't want to commit heresy or anything. By the way, someone should go and look up what the original meaning of the word "Heresy" was and get back to me.

The Stoa is now available for some one else to teach a class. Have a nice evening.

--Zavost